Archive for the ‘Viruses’ Category

Gates Founded CEPI Seeks Billions For Next ‘Pandemic’ as WHO and World Bank Deploy $7 Billion Across 75 Nations

Remember Problem, Reaction, Solution?  Well, here it is in action.

https://jonfleetwood.substack.com/p/bill-gatesfounded-cepi-seeks-25-billion?

Bill Gates–Founded CEPI Seeks $2.5 Billion for Next Pandemic as WHO and World Bank Deploy $7 Billion Across 75 Nations

Powerful international institutions funding pandemic-capable influenza research are now simultaneously building the global response system designed to confront those threats.

An unprecedented level of international funding and coordination is now underway to expand the global pandemic response system, with at least $9.5 billion committed by the World Health Organization (WHO), the World Bank, and a Bill Gates-founded vaccine coalition to finance the worldwide surveillance networks, laboratories, and vaccines tied to future pandemic declarations.

The Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI)—founded in 2017 by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, the World Economic Forum, and national governments—announced last week that it is now seeking an additional $2.5 billion to expand its pandemic vaccine financing programs. (See link for article)

_____________

**Comment**

Journalist Jon Fleetwood asks a poignant question:

When Does Pandemic Conflict of Interest Become a National Security Threat?

Both Gates and the WHO financially benefit from ‘pandemics,’ with Gates being a top contributor to the WHO in a ‘you wash my back, I’ll wash yours,’ arrangement, as well as to biolabs performing ‘gain of function’ experiments. It’s a nice, cozy arrangement and financially lucrative to all involved, well, except for all the people who get sick and/or die.

A recent study was not able to produce one case of the flu despite prolonged close contact; however, a federally run experiment funded by NIAID, DARPA, Gates, and your tax dollars deliberately infected 80 Americans with an engineered flu virus and of the 74 analyzed, 53 became contagious. Oh, and ‘vaxxed’ shedders displayed a hyper-inflammatory immune response, ‘vaccination’ did not prevent infection, and no details were given whatsoever about biosafety controls, containment, or post infection release criteria.  

Have we learned anything yet?  Feeling safe?

Further, NIAID-funded researchers are engineering a mutant Bird flu virus to ‘expand its host range.’  Current Director of NIAID, Dr. Jeffery Taubenberger just happens to hold a patient on the Bird Flu pandemic ‘vaccine,’ which just happens to be at the center of Trump’s $500 Million ‘Generation Gold Standard‘ Project.  Taubenberger lead the team that sequenced and reconstructed the 1918 ‘Spanish flu’ genome – the deadliest pandemic in modern history.

Well, isn’t this all just nice and cozy?

I’m sure all of this is completely unrelated and kosher.

For more:

 

 

 

Coinfection in Lyme Disease: Clinical Impact, Diagnostic Challenges, and Therapeutic Perspectives

https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2607/14/2/325

Tick-Borne Co-Infection in Lyme Disease: Clinical Impact, Diagnostic Challenges, and Therapeutic Perspectives

by Georgi Popov, Dzhaner Bashchobanov* and Radina Andonova
Clinic of Infectious Diseases, Sofiamed Hospital, 1797 Sofia, Bulgaria
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed.
Microorganisms 202614(2), 325; https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms14020325
Submission received: 8 January 2026 / Revised: 27 January 2026 / Accepted: 28 January 2026 / Published: 30 January 2026
Abstract
Tick-borne co-infections are an increasingly recognized and clinically important aspect of Lyme borreliosis, particularly in regions where Ixodes ticks transmit a wide range of bacterial, protozoan, and viral pathogens. In addition to Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato, these ticks frequently harbor microorganisms such as Babesia spp.,   Anaplasma phagocytophilumEhrlichia spp., Borrelia miyamotoiBartonella spp., and several tick-borne viruses. Co-infections may increase disease severity, prolong symptom duration, and contribute to atypical or overlapping clinical presentations, thereby complicating diagnosis and management. Growing evidence from epidemiological studies, clinical case series, and experimental in vivo and in vitro models indicates that pathogen–pathogen and pathogen–host interactions can modulate immune responses and influence disease progression. Diagnostic challenges arise from non-specific clinical features and limitations of current laboratory methods. From a therapeutic perspective, although standard antibiotic regimens for Lyme disease are effective against some bacterial co-infections, they do not provide coverage for protozoan or viral agents, necessitating pathogen-specific and, in some cases, combination treatment strategies. This review synthesizes current knowledge on the epidemiology, clinical impact, diagnostic limitations, and treatment approaches for tick-borne co-infections associated with Lyme disease, and highlights critical evidence gaps and future research directions to improve patient outcomes.
For more:

Epstein & Gates Financed Research Portal To Control Scientific Discourse

https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/jeffrey-epstein-bill-gates-financed-researchgate-control-scientific-discourse/

‘Muzzled and Muted’: Epstein, Gates Financed Research Portal to Control Scientific Discourse

In a series of posts on X, ScienceGuardians revealed that Jeffrey Epstein, Bill Gates and others linked to the Gates Foundation were instrumental in financing ResearchGate, an online scientific research portal. According to ScienceGuardians, the platform was actually developed “as a for-profit business to make big money from science” — with the intent to “control the flow of scientific ideas.”

epstein, gates and money

Jeffrey Epstein and Bill Gates sought to profit from — and exert influence over — scientific publishing and online discourse, according to information in the “Epstein Files” released last month by the U.S. Department of Justice…..

The summary listed ResearchGate, noting that Gates provided $10 million in funding to ResearchGate in 2013. This was part of a Gates-led funding round that attracted $35 million in investments to ResearchGate.

But according to ScienceGuardians, the platform was actually developed “as a for-profit business to make big money from science” — with the intent to “control the flow of scientific ideas” and exert influence over scientific discourse.  (See link for article)

____________

Important Excerpts:

Investors included Goldman Sachs and the Wellcome Trust, led by Jeremy Farrar, Ph.D., architect of key COVID-19 pandemic-era policies and now assistant director-general of the World Health Organization.

Gates and Epstein also helped secure partnerships with the publishers of major scientific journals, including Nature. Published by Springer Nature, it is widely considered one of the “giants” of medical and scientific publishing.

Other Springer publications include Politico, Springer Health, Nature, BioMedCentral, Scientific American and Nature Medicine — publisher of the infamous “Proximal Origin” paper in 2020, used to support the claim that SARS-CoV-2 had a natural origin.

Hopefully by now it’s clear why COVID messaging was so tyrannically one-sided.  Voices were simply drowned out.  This article shares how sensitive government information has been shared with Epstein.  The Biden administration and corporate media used the “Disinformation Dozen” list to discredit figures like Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Sayer Ji. Social media platforms deplatformed those included on the list.

According to Ji, the same dark-money infrastructure they used to destroy political opponents were redeployed the identical playbook against U.S.-based health publishers and independent media.”

Internal documents leaked in 2024 showed that CCDH sought to launch “Black Ops” against Kennedy and “kill Musk’s Twitter” — now known as X. “Black ops” refers to secret operations carried out by governments or other organizations that hide their involvement.

Never trust these agencies again.  Ever.  Remain vigilant and do your own research. Whatever the CDC/FDA/NIH are peddling – do the exact opposite!

For more:

During Covid-19, one member of this small group of unaccountable actors, British medical researcher who was previously the director of the Wellcome Trust, Jeremy Farrar, has been given almost absolute power over designing the WHO’s global response to the pandemic.

“There is no peacetime any more…Preparedness and readiness is a constant and needs to be part of the fabric of society… My preference would be to streamline the architecture of global health with the WHO in the middle of the web, convening, advising, guiding and providing an emergency response… Crumbs from the table will not cut it in the era of pandemics.” ~ Jeremy Farrar (2021)  [4]

 

 

Study: Unable to Produce ONE Case of Flu Despite Prolonged Close Contact But NIAID-Funded Scientists Engineer Mutant Flu Virus & ‘Expand its Host Range’

More on the ‘virus,’ ‘no virus,’ debate…..

https://jonfleetwood.substack.com/p/niaid-funded-scientists-tried-to?

NIAID-Funded Scientists Tried to Make Influenza Spread—They Couldn’t Despite 80+ Hours of Close Human Exposure: Journal ‘PLOS Pathogens’

Researchers engineered real-world transmission conditions using infected volunteers and sealed indoor exposure sessions, but no secondary infections were detected.

A new peer-reviewed study reports that researchers were unable to produce a single confirmed case of influenza transmission in a controlled human exposure experiment, despite prolonged close contact between infected individuals and healthy volunteers.

The study, published last month in PLOS Pathogens, tested whether naturally infected people could transmit influenza to others under tightly controlled indoor conditions designed to facilitate spread.

Transmission did not occur.

“[N]o transmission was observed in this study,” the authors confirm.

Researchers recruited individuals with confirmed influenza infection and placed them in repeated exposure sessions with healthy participants inside a sealed hotel-based quarantine environment.

Volunteers interacted face-to-face, shared objects, and spent hours together in a room with intentionally low ventilation—conditions chosen to support transmission.

Even under these circumstances, no recipient developed influenza-like illness, tested PCR-positive, or showed serological evidence of infection.  (See link for article)

_____________

**Comment**

Even the most hardened skeptic must scratch his head on this one.

Authors give possible reasons for the unexpected outcome:

  • the sick weren’t coughing enough
  • people had immune protection
  • airflow quickly diluted exhaled breath, reducing exposure

Fleetwood points out the exact same thing was found with COVID challenge studies. In other words, exposed volunteers failed to produce sustained infections.

This experiment has been repeated numerous times now showing the same result: nadda.  Going all the way back to the 1918 influenza pandemic, an experiment was conducted on 62 prisoners:

injected with infected lung tissue from sick or deceased patients, have infected tissue dropped in their eyes, and sprayed in the nose and mouth with infectious aerosols. Others would see mucus taken from critically ill patients and put it into the noses and throats of prisoners. In other parts of the trials, experimenters would take the blood of the sick and inject it into the healthy, to see if it was spread through infectious microorganisms in the blood.

Not one got ill or died.

What nobody is saying here is that viruses don’t exist.  But, there is a camp that asserts just that.  Go here for the history of this camp.  I would say these challenge studies don’t help the virus camp.

One thing is sure: exposure alone is not enough to make someone sick.

Which makes you wonder about the purpose of this……

https://jonfleetwood.substack.com/p/niaid-funded-scientists-engineer?

NIAID-Funded Scientists Engineer Mutant Influenza Virus and ‘Expand its Host Range’: Journal ‘Nature Communications’

Gain-of-function flu pathogen acquires new cell entry function, expands infection capability.

Scientists funded by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) engineered influenza viruses and introduced mutations that expanded the virus’s host range—an outcome that the National Institutes of Health (NIH) itself formally defines as gain-of-function research under a 2025 Executive Order implementation notice.

The study, published in Nature Communicationslast week, confirms the work was funded through a NIAID influenza research center.

The authors state:

“Funding was also provided, in part, by … CRIPT (Center for Research on Influenza Pathogenesis and Transmission), a National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) funded Center for Influenza Research and Response (CEIRR, contract 75N93021C00014…).”

The CEIRR network is one of NIAID’s primary federally funded influenza research programs.

The current Director of NIAID—allowing such risky influenza lab engineering—is Dr. Jeffery Taubenberger, who holds a patent on the technology behind the Trump administration’s $500 million influenza vaccine platform.

The same federal agency funding the creation of mutated influenza viruses is led by the man who helped invent—and could profit from—the vaccine meant to fight them.

Moreover, the study comes as Congress and President Donald Trump have enacted a new law allocating more than $5.5 billion in taxpayer funding for pandemic preparedness, with influenza—the same pathogen engineered in these experiments—named as the only virus explicitly identified in the statute.

Funding for the experiment also came from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA).

(See link for article)

______________

**Comment**

According to attorney Tom Renz, the scuttle that dangerous ‘gain of function’ research was recently banned due to an Executive Order, is false.  Rather, it’s codified and allowed under new regulation.  It’s all good if you are compliant with current regulation.

“Gain of Function” has now been legitimized and sanctioned.  Far from being banned.

The ‘no virus’ camp rolls their eyes at all of this because according to them, none of this exists.

Something exists and something is making people sicker than dogs. How about we find out what is causing these illnesses killing people and STOP funding research making pathogens deadlier?

For more:

Regarding Wisconsin:

 

 

Key Architect of ‘Disinformation Dozen’ List Resigns After ‘Epstein Files’ Reveal Tangled Web of Censorship

Why the Epstein Files need to be completely open and free for public viewing…..with no redactions!

https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/morgan-mcsweeney-ccdh-disinformation-dozen-resigns-epstein-files-censorship

Key Architect of ‘Disinformation Dozen’ List Resigns After ‘Epstein Files’ Reveal Tangled Web of Censorship

The 2021 publication of “The Disinformation Dozen” list of 12 “leading online anti-vaxxers” sparked efforts to discredit U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Sayer Ji and other outspoken critics of COVID-19 pandemic policies and vaccines. Five years later, the release of the “Epstein Files” has led to the resignation of one of the list’s architects — Morgan McSweeney.

morgan mcsweeney and CCDH logo

The 2021 publication of “The Disinformation Dozen” list of 12 “leading online anti-vaxxers” sparked efforts to discredit U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Sayer Ji and other outspoken critics of COVID-19 pandemic policies and vaccines.

Five years later, the release of the “Epstein Files” has led to the resignation of one of the list’s architects — Morgan McSweeney.

McSweeney, chief of staff to the U.K. Prime Minister Keir Starmer, resigned Sunday. In 2018, he co-founded what later became known as the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), which published the “Disinformation Dozen” list.

McSweeney’s resignation stemmed from his prior support for Peter Mandelson, former U.K. ambassador to the U.S.

Mandelson is implicated in the Epstein Files for his close ties to disgraced financier and registered sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. McSweeney had advised Starmer to appoint Mandelson to his ambassadorial post.

Starmer removed Mandelson from his post in September 2025, after emails between Mandelson and Epstein were made public. In the emails, Mandelson suggested that Epstein’s 2008 conviction for soliciting sex from a child prostitute was wrongful and should be overturned.

The Epstein Files also showed that Mandelson shared sensitive government information with Epstein. The U.K. Metropolitan Police launched a criminal investigation of Mandelson, while Starmer apologized to Epstein’s sex-trafficking victims.

In his resignation letter, McSweeney took “full responsibility” for advising Starmer to appoint Mandelson.

But Ji, listed as one of the “Disinformation Dozen,” told The Defender McSweeney’s resignation shows that “the architecture behind a decade of political censorship is coming into view.”

“The same political culture that normalized backroom routing of power, deniability, and proxy enforcement is the culture that produced CCDH — and shielded it from scrutiny while it reshaped public discourse on both sides of the Atlantic,” Ji wrote on Substack.

In its early years, CCDH targeted left-wing political figures and independent media outlets in the U.K. with claims of antisemitism. Later, it targeted “misinformation” and “disinformation” in the U.S.

The Biden administration and corporate media used the “Disinformation Dozen” list to discredit figures like Kennedy and Ji. Social media platforms deplatformed those included on the list.

Internal documents leaked in 2024 showed that CCDH sought to launch “Black Ops” against Kennedy and “kill Musk’s Twitter” — now known as X. “Black ops” refers to secret operations carried out by governments or other organizations that hide their involvement.

The Epstein Files don’t contain evidence indicating Epstein was involved in CCDH’s operations, Ji said. But they do reveal an “operational lineage” connecting Epstein to figures like Mandelson and McSweeney, revealing “the hidden origins of CCDH — and the elite networks now illuminated by the Epstein files.”

“The Epstein files help explain why censorship became so aggressive,” said Seamus Bruner, director of research at the Government Accountability Institute. “CCDH and similar entities functioned less as neutral watchdogs and more as enforcement mechanisms — protecting systems, not public discourse.”

CCDH exported UK censorship infrastructure to the U.S.

McSweeney worked closely with Mandelson as far back as 2001, and he was also the key figure behind CCDH’s launch, according to Ji.

“McSweeney conceived, incubated and structurally engineered the operation that would later become CCDH — first as a factional political weapon inside the Labour Party, and later as a transatlantic NGO [nongovernmental organization] deployed against journalists, publishers, doctors, and political dissidents,” Ji wrote.

According to Ji, much public attention has focused on CCDH CEO Imran Ahmed — who is now facing deportation from the U.S. — and his role in online censorship. “If Ahmed was the executor. McSweeney was the designer,” Ji wrote.

In 2018, McSweeney and Ahmed co-founded Brixton Endeavours Limited, which they renamed to CCDH in 2019. According to Ji, Jeremy Corbyn’s surprising electoral success in 2017 prompted the organization’s launch.

Ji wrote that McSweeney, a self-described “centrist,” viewed Corbyn, who represented the left wing of the U.K. Labour Party, as a threat. The two launched attacks against people and media outlets who supported Corbyn, accusing them of antisemitism. The attacks resulted in several outlets and social media accounts being deplatformed.

The attacks also contributed to Corbyn’s fall from power and Starmer’s subsequent rise.

According to Ji, CCDH “emerged directly” from Labour Together and a parallel group, Stop Funding Fake News, launched by McSweeney and Ahmed.

Ji said CCDH used “the same staff, and the same dark-money infrastructure they used to destroy Jeremy Corbyn — then redeployed the identical playbook against U.S.-based health publishers and independent media.”

Ji said that McSweeney sent 100 Labour Party operatives to the U.S. to support the Democratic Party in swing states before the 2024 presidential election — resulting in a complaint to the Federal Election Commission.

‘The same dark funding. Only the targets changed’

Once it was active in the U.S., CCDH didn’t limit its activities to attempted election interference. Instead, the organization “turned its attention to American citizens — health freedom advocates, independent journalists, and public commentators who questioned COVID-era policies.”

Ji wrote:

“The rebranding was seamless. The same organizational infrastructure. The same demonetization playbook. The same reliance on unfalsifiable moral accusationsaccusations where the denial is treated as confirmation. The same exploitation of institutional trust. The same dark funding. Only the targets changed.”

The “Disinformation Dozen” report highlights CCDH’s efforts to target alleged disinformation and misinformation. Facebook’s own internal analysis would later contradict the CCDH’s claim that the “Disinformation Dozen” was responsible for 65% of anti-vaccine content online, Ji said. But “precision was never the point.”

“Within months,” the White House cited the “Disinformation Dozen” label.Social media platforms accelerated deplatforming. Advertising revenue collapsed,” Ji said.

Ji said CCDH “did not act alone.” CCDH’s activities were aligned with those of federal agencies like the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and with those of the U.K.-based Institute for Strategic Dialogue (ISD), which received funding from the Gates Foundation.

CCDH had also received funding from the Open Society Foundations, linked to financier George Soros.

Pure tyranny dressed up as public health’

Even before the publication of the “Disinformation Dozen,” ISD endorsed CCDH and its efforts to target “misinformation” and “disinformation.” In 2019, ISD, in collaboration with the BBC, published a report that included Ji’s GreenMedInfo on a list of “disinformation-hosting websites” provided by fact-checking group NewsGuard.

In 2022, investigative journalist Kris Ruby published whistleblower testimony showing that CCDH was one of the organizations providing Twitter with censorship word lists used to identify and target users who posted on selected topics.

According to Ruby, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention under Biden “played a significant role in the creation of these word lists.”

“This was not about misinformation. It was about permission structures — who may speak, who may be erased, and who decides, without democratic accountability,” Ji wrote.

Several people named in the “Disinformation Dozen” said they felt vindicated by the Epstein Files revelations and McSweeney’s resignation.

Charlene Bollinger, founder of The Truth About Vaccines and The Truth About Cancer, said she is “grateful to be vindicated — but more grateful that the world is now seeing what we have seen and said all along … as we worked tirelessly to tell the truth about Big Pharma, the medical mafia and the vaccine cartel.”

“The vindication is structural,” Ji told The Defender. “The files demonstrate that the ‘Disinformation Dozen’ narrative was not about truth — it was about pre-emptive containment of critics who were identifying real power structures too early.”

“What we’re looking at is pure tyranny dressed up as public health,” said chiropractor Ben Tapper.

Epstein’s connection to CCDH and ‘Disinformation Dozen’

Epstein does not appear to be directly linked to CCDH. But the “same political culture of deniable backroom operations that made the Epstein network functional also produced CCDH,” Ji said.

Within this network, Epstein “functioned as a switchboard — routing access, capital, and influence between domains designed never to appear connected,” Ji wrote. The domains included government policy, Wall Street, pandemic financing, narrative enforcement and access to elite figures such as Bill Gates.

Ji said revelations from the Epstein Files, released Jan. 30, showing the extent of Mandelson’s dealings with Epstein, are also damning for McSweeney. He was “widely reported to be Peter Mandelson’s protégé,” with ties dating back to 2001, when McSweeney worked for Mandelson on Labour’s election campaign.

Mandelson’s social ties to Epstein were known before the files were released. But they were widely viewed as a blip on an otherwise distinguished political career. Now, “that framing is no longer available,” Ji wrote.

In a 2009 email to JPMorgan Chase executive Jes Staley, Epstein said Mandelson was “for all intents and purposes … deputy prime minister” of the U.K.

In a 2009 email exchange, Mandelson and Epstein discussed the former’s efforts to lobby to reduce a tax on bankers’ bonuses. In an email to Epstein, Mandelson wrote that JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon should “mildly threaten” then-U.K. Chancellor Alistair Darling as part of these lobbying efforts.

The Epstein Files revealed evidence showing that Epstein later worked with JPMorgan Chase to develop and finance pandemic preparedness infrastructure globally.

“The political culture that produced CCDH — the culture of backroom operations, dark money, deniable proxies, and weaponized moral framing — is the same political culture that made the Epstein network possible,” Ji wrote.

CCDH is under congressional investigation, and deportation proceedings against Ahmed are ongoing.

In a filing with the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York earlier this month, the U.S. Department of State described Ahmed as a “key collaborator with the Biden administration on weaponizing the national security bureaucracy to censor U.S. citizens and pressure U.S. companies into censoring.”

This article was originally published by The Defender — Children’s Health Defense’s News & Views Website under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. Please consider subscribing to The Defender or donating to Children’s Health Defense.

Related articles in The Defender

_____________

**Comment**

I wish that the worst thing about the Epstein Files was censorship (which is bad enough); however, it’s much, much darker than that:

Epstein ran a multinational blackmail and trafficking operation that compromised politicians, scientists, business titans, and royalty across multiple countries. He had connections to CIA, Mossad, MI6. He named a bank account after Baal, the ancient Canaanite child sacrifice deity. He built a temple on his island with pillars modeled after Solomon’s Temple. He traded in human beings the way most people trade stocks, and he did it for decades with the protection of multiple intelligence agencies and the willing blindness of everyone who benefited from his network.

Bill Gates caught an STD from trafficked Russian girls and allegedly begged Epstein for secret antibiotics so he could dose his wife Melinda without her knowledge.

Harvard scientists emailed Epstein discussing hormonal experimentation on toddlers and the “sexual economics” of transitioning children, written like a commodity trader analyzing market segments.

A mother sold her baby to Epstein and sent a photo with a thank-you note for the wire transfer.

The emails reference torture videos. They reference “stage three” victims who were abused young enough to “gradually develop special and supernatural abilities” from the trauma. They reference ritual sacrifice.

The word “pizza” appears over 900 times, matching FBI-documented coded language used by trafficking networks. Source

This is way deeper and uglier than censorship.

Go here to read Sayer Ji’s exposé on how the Files expose the JPMorgan, Gates, Epstein pipeline of donor-advised funds, vaccine finance, and pre-positioned profit for ‘pandemics’:” 20 Year Architecture Behind Pandemics As a Business Model With Bill Gates at the Center.”

‘Epstein is not the scandal itself but a visible crack in a much larger structure of financial, religious, and political power operating above nation-states.’ Lone Wolf (in summarizing Paul Cudenec’s article: Epstein, the Rothschilds and the global cabal)

Here, Representative Massie explains that the files are bigger than Watergate, Iran-Contra, and spans four presidential cycles, intelligence, billionaires, and both political parties.

If you want to understand the darkness that is unfolding, you need to read this to understand the worldview that came first.

While the public deserves clarity: