Powassan virus on the up-tick

Paul Smith’s research shows spread risks funding cut

From left, seniors, Anna Mehner, Becky Raymond, Lee Ann Sporn, Katherine Gale, William Tobin, Mason Fountain, Benjamin McInerney and Lillian Meunier are seven of the eight students in Sporn’s class, which tracked the deadly tick-borne Powassan virus in the North Country. The eighth student is Jared Barnhart. (Enterprise photo — Aaron Cerbone)

PAUL SMITHS — A group of Paul Smith’s College students, researching the tick-borne Powassan virus for the state, has discovered that the disease is prevalent throughout the North Country.

Though professor Lee Ann Sporn said research on the Powassan spread is just starting, the group may lose its state funding in March.

The students, who are the first and only researchers of Powassan in the North Country, found that around 25 to 50 percent of deer in the northern half of the Adirondacks tested positive for exposure to Powassan, less than 25 percent were exposed in the southern and most eastern parts and 75 to 100 percent were exposed in the western edge.

“This was completely student driven,” Sporn said. “The state Department of Health was incredibly pleased with what we were able to do.”

The study involved students — funded by the state Senate Task Force on Lyme and other Tick Borne Diseases, and doing research through the Adirondack Watershed Institute — working with deer processors and hunters from St. Lawrence, Franklin, Essex, Clinton, Washington and Warren counties to establish the northern edge of the Powassan virus’ reach.

The pipette and vial used to take a sample of deer blood come in a kit with rubber gloves and a cloth. These kits were used by Paul Smith’s College students to research the tick-borne Powassan virus. (Enterprise photo — Aaron Cerbone)

“The punchline is there really wasn’t a northern edge,” Sporn said.

Powassan does not affect everyone exposed to it, but the ones who are effected can develop a serious brain infection, for which there is no vaccine or antibodies. Powassan has a 10 percent mortality rate, mimics dengue and can be misdiagnosed as the flu. Those who recover from it can often have neurological damage.

The transfer of Powassan from a tick to a human can take as little as 15 minutes.

Powassan is often found in the ticks and deer of southern New York. However, until around two years ago it was unheard of in the North Country.

“It’s probably driven by climate change,” Sporn said of the northward crawl. “Warmer and wetter, with less extended periods of cold.

“In some areas of the state (the south) nearly all deer have antibodies to Powassan,” Sporn continued.

Despite its high prevalence in deer, Powassan is rarely found in humans.

There are under 50 human cases of Powassan ever recorded in New York. However, nine of those were in the past two years, including three in Saratoga County in 2017, one which was fatal.

Powassan-carrying ticks are also pretty rare. Sporn estimates that less than 1 percent are positive in the Tri-Lakes area.

Students tested deer blood because it acts as a sentinel for Powassan in the area. Deer can be bit by thousands of ticks over their lifetime, and once a tick with Powassan bites a deer the deer creates antibodies in its blood which last the rest of its life.

The blood came from samples collected by processors such as Woods and Water and Blue Line Sports, outdoors stores in Saranac Lake, individual hunters and processors around the North Country. Sporn said she wanted to thank everyone that contributed to the study because she was able to get around 100 samples, evenly spread around the park.

“We wouldn’t have done that without the processors,” Sporn said. “What they did provided so much important information.”

Sporn said she doesn’t want this new information to cause panic, but said people shouldn’t be cavalier about it either.

“It doesn’t mean that people are going to get the disease, because there are other places where ticks test positive and no human cases show up,”Sporn said. “No one really understands the relationship between positive ticks, positive deer and human cases.

“Just because you’re exposed doesn’t mean you’re going to get sick,” she added. “The risk to humans is incredibly low.”

To avoid being bitten, Sporn recommends dressing to cover all lower body skin, wearing repellents and being knowledgeable of where ticks will be.

She said to tuck pants into socks, wear light colors to easily see ticks and be aware when walking through high grasses. She said the locally made repellent Wild Wood is effective.

Sporn said it is okay to eat and touch deer infected with it.

Funding troubles

The study was funded through the state Senate Task Force on Lyme and other Tick Borne Diseases, a Republican initiative, with the support of state Sen. Betty Little, R-Queensbury. It is up to the majority party to organize the task force. Democrats took the Senate majority in last year’s election and has not done that yet.

Last year Sporn said she received $30,000 in funding from the task force, including $5,000 for the Powassan project. She is asking for the same level of funding this year.

Sporn said she has been contacting Senate Democrats using a list supplied by Little. Funding will need to be secured for the task force and research by the time the state’s budget is voted on April 1.

Sporn said this research is important for human health in New York, and that it is about catching things early and preempting a health emergency. She wants to research the spread of the virus for several years to see what patterns emerge.

“If you don’t watch over a long time, you may never see that happen,”Sporn said. “I really wish we had done this a few years ago.”

The project also translates its results into public information and literature provided to health clinics and medical professionals to educate them and the public about tick-borne diseases. There is a fair amount of rejection of the research that shows Lyme disease has spread into the Adirondacks by the medical community.

“That’s just kind of human nature, for people to resist the change,” Sporn said.

Sporn said she has talked with the Cloudsplitter Foundation about continuing with private funding. She said the Paul Smith’s students have created a good model for other schools to use to research Powassan or other tick-borne illnesses. She said she has not seen research on if the virus has spread into Vermont or Canada.



Climate change has nothing to do with this:  In this link there is a video showing ticks surviving 3 degrees in snow cover.  Canadian tick researcher, John Scott, has disproven the climate change theory regarding tick expansion and pathogen expansion.  He found that photo-period and songbird migration are behind it.

His study summed up:

  • during bad weather ticks adapt by finding cover
  • warmer temperatures actually reduce tick populations
  • temperature and precipitation have no bearing on tick abundance
  • climate change alarmists have used Canadian studies making 1970 their benchmark for models but didn’t take into account established tick populations that had already been in existence for decades, centuries, or even millennia at northern latitudes
  • Black-legged ticks require 14 hours of daylight to molt.  Photoperiod is innate and can not be altered by the climate
  • Yearly bidirectional, songbird migration in spring and fall is behind tick expansion and the climate change model actually reflects migratory flight not warmer futuristic temperatures

Although Scott’s study specifically deals with Lyme disease, tick and pathogen spread is the same regardless of the disease.

Scott’s study:

For an interview with Scott:

“The climate change range expansion model is what the authorities have been using to rationalize how they have done nothing for more than thirty years. It’s a huge cover-up scheme that goes back to the 1980’s. The grandiose scheme was a nefarious plot to let doctors off the hook from having to deal with this debilitating disease. I caught onto it very quickly. Most people have been victims of it ever since.  This climate change ‘theory’ is all part of a well-planned scheme. Even the ticks are smarter than the people who’ve concocted this thing.  Climate change has nothing to do with tick movement. Blacklegged ticks are ecoadaptive, and tolerate wide temperature fluctuations…..It’s all a red herring to divert your attention.”- John Scott

Due to this research, researchers need to quit going down the rabbit-hole of climate change as it has not and will not help patients one iota.