Definition of the Term According to the CDC the definition of Lyme disease as:
“Lyme disease is an infection caused by the bacterium Borrelia burgdorferi. In the majority of cases, it is successfully treated with oral antibiotics. Physicians sometimes describe patients who have non-specific symptoms (like fatigue, pain, and joint and muscle aches) after the treatment of Lyme disease as having Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome (PTLDS) or Post Lyme Disease Syndrome (PLDS). The cause of PTLDS “is not known.”
The CDC also dismisses the use of the term “Chronic Lyme Disease” (CLD), arguing that this term is confusing in the scientific community and has been used at times to describe symptoms in patients who “never had actual or past contact” with Borrelia Burgdorferi infection[1].
In summary: For the CDC, Post-treatment of Lyme disease syndrome (PTLDS) is of “unknown cause” and in addition the term “Chronic Lyme Disease” (CLD) should not be used.
Definition of the term According to the researchers: Lyme disease is caused by a bacterium Borrelia Burgorferi. Some patients show persistent neurological and organic symptoms (Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome (PTLDS), even after proper antibiotic therapy. The PTLDS symptoms include: cognitive changes: memory loss, verbal flexibility, association changes, speeds of thought, fatigue, musculoskeletal pain, weakness. It is thought that the cause of this is a chronic encephalopathy caused by the Borrelia burgdorferi when it reaches the brain[2,9-15].
Also many, perhaps most researchers recognize the term “Chronic Lyme Disease (CLD), widely described in the literature[2], and could be considered the same Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome (PTLDS). In addition, it is considered that in many cases the diagnosis was made late due to failures in the blood tests and resistance to the treatment with antibiotics.
In summary: for the scientific community, the term “post-treatment of Lyme disease syndrome (PTLDS)” is a reality and, in many cases, the cause of this is a chronic encephalopathy that causes the symptoms. The failure of the treatment with antibiotics, or the late establishment of it by misdiagnoses, could contribute to the symptomatology.
Chronologic Evolution
Decade from 1990 to 2000
In the year 1991 Krupp et al[3].; describes 15 patients treated for Lyme disease who complained of persistent cognitive difficulty after 6 to 7 months of treatment with antibiotic therapy; they were compared with 10 healthy controls. Post-Lyme patients showed a marked deterioration in cognitive tests: memory loss mainly in selective recognition. Memory deterioration did not correlate with anti-Borrelia burgdorferi antibodies titers in the blood or cerebrospinal fluid. No evidence of alterations in the magnetic resonances was found in the affected patients, also symptoms of depression. The authors conclude that it is an encephalopathy of unknown cause, where factors such as the sequelae of systemic infection by Borrelia and other toxic metabolic factors may be partly responsible for these symptoms[3].
Perhaps this represents the first study in Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome (PTLDS), or Post-Lyme Syndrome (PLS) because patients were evaluated months after receiving treatment and presented neurological damage symptomatology in this case chronic encephalopathy[3].
Note: In all the previous studies of Lyme disease the term Post-Lyme Treatment Syndrome (PLTDS) is not mentioned; they describe chronic manifestations as part of the second or late phase of Lyme disease, but not this term until 1991 where these researchers publish the study[2-3].
1995: After the description of Krupp et al., another scientists: Benke, et al.[4], in the year of 1995, published a study on 20 patients with Lyme Borreliosis previously diagnosed several years earlier, with an average of 4.3 years after the acute phase of Lyme, compared with a control group; This study revealed that patients with Lyme revealed deficits in verbal memory, mental flexibility, verbal associative functions and vocal articulation. The authors suggest that these findings are similar to those reported by Krupp et al. in 1991 and reaffirm that it is an encephalopathy associated with a long-term neuropsychological deficit that predominantly affects internal functions[4].
1996: One year later Bujak, et al. in 1996 published a study of 23 patients after had Lyme positively tested with ELISA, and previously treated with standard antibiotic regimens for the disease; neurocognitive impairment, persistent arthralgia, fatigue and memory loss were evaluated, finding the following facts: 7 patients (30 %) had fibromyalgia, 3(13 %) had chronic fatigue syndrome and 22 of 23, they complained about memory problems or decreased concentration. The scores for the attention scale, verbal memory, visual memory, sleep problems, mood swings and depression symptoms were higher for Post Lyme patients (PLS) than the normal.
The authors conclude that despite treatment with appropriate antibiotics for Lyme disease, sequelae mainly neurocognitive disorders, persistent arthralgias and fatigue can arise[5].
1997: In this year, Gaudino, et al. published a study to evaluate the differences and similarities between chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and post-Lyme syndrome (PLS) studying 25 patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) with exclusion criteria for Lyme disease, 56 healthy controls and 38 patients with Post Lyme syndrome (PLS), seropositive for Borrelia burgdorferi with positive criteria by the CDC for Lyme, who presented symptoms of severe fatigue 6 months after having complied with the treatment of antibiotics for Lyme disease. All the patients underwent structured psychiatric interviews, evaluating: attention tests, verbal memory, verbal fluency and motor speed.
Patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and Post Lyme syndrome (PLS) were similar in several somatic symptoms and in the psychiatric profile. Patients with PLS had a worse performance on cognitive tests compared to healthy controls.
The authors conclude that despite the overlap of symptoms, patients with Post Lyme Syndrome (PLS) show greater cognitive deficits than patients with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) compared to healthy controls. This fact became more evident among patients with PLS who lacked premorbid psychiatric disease[6].
1998: Bloom, et al. studied 5 children from the neurocognitive point of view after having been diagnosed with Lyme. They were treated for 2 to 4 weeks with intravenous ceftriaxone and evaluated comprehensively including detailed neuropsychiatric tests. The main objective of the study was to consider the possibility that Lyme disease after treatment left a sequel in children as well, as it had already been demonstrated in adults.
The 5 children were followed up for a period of 2 to 7 years after the treatment with antibiotic (ceftriaxone) and it was found that months after the treatment the children after having had the classic erythema migrans, cranial neuropathy or Lyme arthritis, developed behavioral changes, forgetfulness, decreased school performance, headache, fatigue and in two cases complex seizure disorders.
The five patients were found IgG antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi in serum, intrathecal IgG antibodies and two of them pleocytosis of the Cerebro Spinal Fluid (CSF). Despite normal intellectual functioning, the five children had mild to moderate impairments in auditory or visual sequential processing.
The authors conclude that children can develop neurocognitive symptoms together with or after the classic manifestations of Lyme disease, and attribute it to an infectious or postinfectious encephalopathy related to Borrelia burgdorferi, confirming previous studies in adults[7].
In this study it was demonstrated that the Post-Treatment Syndrome of Lyme Disease (PTLDS) not only affects adults, but also children, and it is reaffirmed that the cause of it is an encephalopathy caused by the infection by the Borrelia burgdorferi.
1999: In the year of 1999 Elkins et al. published a work on 30 patients with Post Lyme Syndrome (PLS), who were surveyed to determine the neuropsychological status found as a fundamental aspect: the mood of PLS participants was characterized by reduced levels of positive affect (PA) and typical levels of negative affect. Authors conclude that these symptoms are the most useful markers in patients with Post Lyme Syndrome (PLS)[8].
That same year Kaplan, et al. conducted a study where they claim that a small group of patients with Lyme develop encephalopathic symptoms months to years after diagnosis and treatment. The most common symptoms reported were fatigue, memory loss, sleep disorders and depression with a controversial etiology of the syndrome (PLS). The study was done comparing patients with Lyme and abnormal Cerebro Spinal Fluid (CSF), patients with Lyme and normal CSF and healthy controls. Both groups with Lyme showed memory deficits, but more accentuated and measurable in those with abnormal CSF; they also showed higher score in the depression in relation to healthy controls[9].
2000-2001: In 2001 Klempner, et al. conducted a study to test the efficacy of antibiotic treatment in Lyme-positive patients with persistent symptoms and a history of Lyme disease. Two groups of patients were studied: 78 seropositive patients and 51 seronegative patients for Borrelia burgdorferi. Patients received intravenous ceftriaxone, 2 g daily for 30 days, followed by oral doxycycline, 200 mg daily for 60 days, or corresponding oral and intravenous placebos. Each patient had well documented and treated Lyme disease, and had persistent musculoskeletal pain, or dysesthesia associated with fatigue. The authors conclude that there is a considerable deterioration in health-related quality of life among patients with persistent symptoms despite prior treatment for acute Lyme disease. In these two trials treatment with oral or intravenous antibiotics for 90 days did not improve symptoms more than placebo[10].
Morgen, et al. performed a brain Magnetic Resonance (MR) study in 27 patients with post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome to try to help identify the pathological mechanisms of the disease. Of the total, four (4) patients had focal neurological deficits, recurrent remitting disease and lesions in a typical electron microscopy (EM) distribution; 23 (85 %) patients presented non-focal symptoms, such as fatigue, subjective memory deficiencies and mood disorders. Twelve of these patients (44%) had normal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); 10 (37 %) had mainly punctate and subcortical lesions, and one patient had multiple periventricular lesions.
The authors concluded that in a portion of patients with Lyme disease syndrome after treatment, hyperintensities of the white matter tend to occur in subcortical arteriolar watershed areas and are not-specific[11].
These last two studies show:
- Many patients do not improve with long-term antibiotics after presenting chronic symptoms post Lyme and
- It is demonstrated that there are obvious findings of the damage of the cerebral white matter in post-Lyme patient’s treatment, found by means of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI).
This means that in the line of time and for the 90s and the beginning of the 2000s, a harsh reality is uncovered: Lyme disease is an illness that in many cases becomes chronic, months or years after symptoms begin, even after having disappeared with proper treatment.
The most frequent symptoms of Chronic Lyme Disease (CLD) or Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome (PTLDS):
2001-2018
Chronic Lyme Disease Symptoms:
- Fatigue and lack of resistance
- Nocturnal sweating
- Pale, dark circle under the eyes
- Abdominal pain
- Diarrhea or constipation
- Nausea
- Cardiac anomalies: Lyme carditis
- Orthopedic disorders: sensitivity, spasms and generalized muscle pain, rigidity and / or retarded motion
- Respiratory infections of the superior tract and otitis
- Arthritic disorders and painful joints
- Neurological disorders: Headache Drowsiness, Loss of memory, Convulsions, Facial paralysis, Irritability, Bad mood
- Suicidal thoughts; Anxiety; Anger or rage; Hallucinations
- Eating disorders and humor changes: Cognitive speaking, Speech delay, Reading-writing problems, Problems of vocal articulation, Auditory / visual processing problems, Word selection problems, Dyslexia
- Aggression or violence
- Irritability
- Emotional disorders
- Depression
- Hyperactivity
- Photophobia
- Gastroesophageal reflux with vomiting and coughing
- Secondary eruptions
- Other eruptions
- Ocular problems: posterior cataracts, myopia, stigmatism, conjunctive erythema (Lyme eyes), optical nerve atrophy and / or uveitis
- Sensitivity of skin and noise (hyperacuity)[12-45].
Probably there are more, the evidence is that there really are chronic symptoms in Lyme disease, with or without adequate treatment.